Hello tor-dev folks!

Late last year I started taking a close look at what it would take to support applications on Tor which rely on UDP networking. This was originally to be based on Nick's proposal, 339-udp-over-tor.

The scope of this work so far has been specifically focused on end-user application compatibility, and excludes fundamental changes to Tor's network structure or protocols for now.

This combination of approach and scope left me with more questions than answers, so I started looking deeper into the available solutions along with their expected benefits and risks. This proposal is the result of that investigation.

Please find the text attached, or in the torspec repo as proposal #348:

https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/core/torspec/-/blob/main/proposals/348-udp...

Unlike a typical proposal, this does not recommend any specific change to the Tor implementation. Several possible changes are presented, but ultimately the recommended approach is to use application-specific UDP relays to achieve compatibility.

Integrated approaches are also presented, where Tor does involve itself in the transit of individual datagrams. These approaches offer advantages only when they are also part of a long-term plan to offer transport features beyond those offered by TCP. Until such a plan is in-scope, specific UDP extensions cannot be offered with confidence.

I would appreciate any feedback on this proposal, whether it's about this particular shorter-term context or about longer-term plans to achieve some kind of optional unreliable transport.

Thanks for your time!

--beth