nusenu:
Georg Koppen:
suggestion for an improvement to this process so it will become more accurate/complete (example: May 2021 is incomplete)
Could you elaborate on why you think May 2021 is incomplete and how to fix that?
I believe DAs rejected >1000 relays, but instead of listing their fingerprints on the page, it links to my email which includes a truncated list and does not contain full fingerprints https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2021-May/019644.html
Right. I was for some reason under the assumption we could get away by just linking to your mail. But you are correct, we should do better here. So, I went over our May rejections again and updated the wiki page with the ones I think were missing.[1] Thanks!
The wiki is essentially a public git repository. I am not sure what another public git repository would give us.
it would give users of these lists the possibility to consume it in a much more trivial way without having understand the semantics of the wiki page curl https://gitlab..../$lastmonth-rejection-file
Fair enough. I am not sure yet how we'll make those improvements, but I've filed a ticket[2] at least to not forget about it. My current plan is to tackle that task while re-doing our bad-relay related tooling, which is supposed to start Q1 2022.
Georg
[1] I included an additional fingerprint that I missed while I was at it, as our tooling for that part is obviously not great yet.
[2] https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/network-health/team/-/issues/157