I'm running an exit node using my home ISP (yes, I've read the warnings). My question is: what happens when my ISP changes my IPAddress? Will existing connections to my node be lost and will the node reestablish itself?
Thanks, Chuck Bevitt
Sent from my iPad
On Fri, 01 Feb 2013 15:56:48 +0000, Chuck Bevitt wrote:
I'm running an exit node using my home ISP (yes, I've read the warnings). My question is: what happens when my ISP changes my IPAddress? Will existing connections to my node be lost and will the node reestablish itself?
When your address changes, all circuits and exit connections currently active on your node will die, and furthermore, your exit will still be in the consensus with it's previous address for some time, causing entry nodes to try to build paths through your node using the old address. This will a) obviously fail and b) annoy the pour soul that got your old address. (This goes for non-exit nodes as well.)
If your address changes daily, as is usual on DSL in some parts of the world, it's not the best place to run a relay (IMHO).
Andreas
Thanks for confirming what I suspected. So far, I've been running for a month without an IP change or any feedback from my ISP (Time Warner Road Runner). However, I'm planning to get one of the consumer anonymising VPN services - sort of a virtual ISP - and run my Tor box through that. They can give me a static IP address and I won't have to worry about my ISP objecting to any of the traffic.
Chuck Bevitt
Sent from my iPad
On Feb 2, 2013, at 5:14 AM, Andreas Krey a.krey@gmx.de wrote:
On Fri, 01 Feb 2013 15:56:48 +0000, Chuck Bevitt wrote:
I'm running an exit node using my home ISP (yes, I've read the warnings). My question is: what happens when my ISP changes my IPAddress? Will existing connections to my node be lost and will the node reestablish itself?
When your address changes, all circuits and exit connections currently active on your node will die, and furthermore, your exit will still be in the consensus with it's previous address for some time, causing entry nodes to try to build paths through your node using the old address. This will a) obviously fail and b) annoy the pour soul that got your old address. (This goes for non-exit nodes as well.)
If your address changes daily, as is usual on DSL in some parts of the world, it's not the best place to run a relay (IMHO).
Andreas
-- "Totally trivial. Famous last words." From: Linus Torvalds <torvalds@*.org> Date: Fri, 22 Jan 2010 07:29:21 -0800 _______________________________________________ tor-relays mailing list tor-relays@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays
Does anyone on the list have the luxury of being in the Google Fiber rollout and tried running a relay? I'm curious what their policy might be. -kupo
On Sunday, February 03, 2013 21:37:16 Chuck Bevitt wrote:
Thanks for confirming what I suspected. So far, I've been running for a month without an IP change or any feedback from my ISP (Time Warner Road Runner). However, I'm planning to get one of the consumer anonymising VPN services - sort of a virtual ISP - and run my Tor box through that. They can give me a static IP address and I won't have to worry about my ISP objecting to any of the traffic.
I've been running a middle node on a home Road Runner connection for years. No problem. I started with an exit node but changed a few days later when I found out I couldn't edit Wikipedia or get on some IRC servers.
I would not run a bridge on a Road Runner connection. If I had a connection that changed IP address once a day, which was typical in Germany when I was there, I would run a bridge.
cmeclax
On 2 Feb 2013 00:10, "Chuck Bevitt" Tor@bevitt.ws wrote:
I'm running an exit node using my home ISP (yes, I've read the warnings).
My question is: what happens when my ISP changes my IPAddress? Will existing connections to my node be lost and will the node reestablish itself?
Thanks, Chuck Bevitt
I wouldn't want to put anyone off running an exit, but your home connection isn't the best situation.
How about running a bridge instead? A dynamic IP will be of more use as a bridge rather than relay.
tor-relays@lists.torproject.org