Dear anonymous relay operator,
thank you for adding so many exit relays this month in AS 197226 SPRINT SA (PL) (netblocks 185.234.218.x and 77.87.79.x) we would really like to keep these relays on the network, but they do not have any contact information and MyFamily configuration set - which is required for such big relay groups.
If you are the relay operator, please set a working contactInfo and proper MyFamily configuration and drop an email to bad-relays@lists.torproject.org.
If they do not hear from you, tor directory authorities might decide remove these relays.
It would be a shame to loose so much bandwidth.
thanks for your understanding, nusenu
+---------------------+-----------------+-------------+------------+---------+---------+------------------------------------------+ | first_seen | IP | tor_version | nickname | or_port | contact | fingerprint | +---------------------+-----------------+-------------+------------+---------+---------+------------------------------------------+ | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.37 | 0.3.2.9 | Ceto | 23774 | NULL | 171F6B9BBEC4EBF903CF312CB71CE554F46D8689 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.34 | 0.3.2.9 | Hera | 25565 | NULL | 75712D28F4744FBECAD2E67250644C7258FA71F6 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.36 | 0.3.2.9 | Brizo | 25595 | NULL | A44A3AF8B117665AEB200D0D60674177629EBD18 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.39 | 0.3.2.9 | Helios | 27365 | NULL | 625DC27C540CAE9EF37A8E8851808556AE3E4621 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.46 | 0.3.2.9 | Rhea | 32736 | NULL | 52E2BC36E8B333561C3F36689C1DF9A384B281AC | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.40 | 0.3.2.9 | Hestia | 28736 | NULL | 983221B0D3E68EF8A1D0D6A1EF2DDCF0BA73F710 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.31 | 0.3.2.9 | Aphrodite | 25535 | NULL | 7D8EFB8923173FB89EFE457BA2A6B04D7A9C3395 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.35 | 0.3.2.9 | Zeus | 25575 | NULL | F8ED98209AB9E73420530AA18BABE8AABC4E7619 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.33 | 0.3.2.9 | Hades | 25555 | NULL | 0875C580CC0F0F7E57727AC3C2233F5E6A58AE28 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.42 | 0.3.2.9 | Pallas | 30263 | NULL | D3E518F3749F9FC398261EC60B00B3B1D7535E42 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.38 | 0.3.2.9 | Chaos | 26536 | NULL | 1C49F07147A9113583190D38E58BA40DBECFB9F7 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.43 | 0.3.2.9 | Styx | 28736 | NULL | D6FC8F1E0FB2FC3AC4634FC26E4E1E4D7E1FB558 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.41 | 0.3.2.9 | Nyx | 29096 | NULL | 8B200C067525B70930C4D6CB5DE4C7320B0418AC | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.44 | 0.3.2.9 | Tyche | 29736 | NULL | F76368EC7009FB98F81544473B2F709859FB5327 | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.32 | 0.3.2.9 | Apollo | 25545 | NULL | 830227075292332360349D7A5842B1125004DC6D | | 2018-01-17 22:00:00 | 185.234.218.45 | 0.3.2.9 | Uranus | 31837 | NULL | 01F6F2FA7921681EF6CF9DD327D8E1531B249B78 | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 77.87.79.46 | 0.3.2.9 | Artemis | 29384 | NULL | 65B2D3A0E002704B32B751C4238983D83297E5FB | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 185.234.218.49 | 0.3.2.9 | Maia | 32736 | NULL | ECC5026169EDC6012244B06C2C8C9E90A4574077 | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 77.87.79.49 | 0.3.2.9 | Astra | 29374 | NULL | B4FEC3BD7FF7D269490A5DDCD5B96799BC46489A | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 185.234.218.50 | 0.3.2.9 | Heracles | 31945 | NULL | 94D951D305DEFBBF2552BBDD9C919B09633DDA24 | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 77.87.79.47 | 0.3.2.9 | Hypnos | 25363 | NULL | 537DD2E2D2F026FA9CD210E4B854584762DD9DB6 | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 185.234.218.48 | 0.3.2.9 | Proteus | 28373 | NULL | 7F6DF29D2E0A82834E45AC210990B855802752B6 | | 2018-01-17 23:00:00 | 185.234.218.47 | 0.3.2.9 | Peitha | 28342 | NULL | 6716D11B3D43EA12EC883AA45A600EA277946A39 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.59 | 0.3.2.9 | Charon | 32734 | NULL | 7868248CD8FEE709AEAC0D13F1E30F79EC02D4C4 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.60 | 0.3.2.9 | Nemesis | 27364 | NULL | 54DC9A823CDFAB833590B4E4AE7EC386F38E2EB2 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.56 | 0.3.2.9 | Sirens | 35736 | NULL | AA545B49FE9AE5FC4B2295330E77EAD7BA228AEC | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.52 | 0.3.2.9 | Erotes | 28374 | NULL | 36876E90176DBE3395A3EE8A2584FE7C3513C3C6 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.57 | 0.3.2.9 | Eleus | 28374 | NULL | F47044B9A265994F17EE02FBDA2046DB1A48E6F6 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.55 | 0.3.2.9 | Doris | 33625 | NULL | 9D30457253C5F43AAF38D6356C2B1E8CE4D4672D | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.53 | 0.3.2.9 | Astra | 34948 | NULL | C486FA81814E1EA9E6B4585205816B6CBF96445F | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.54 | 0.3.2.9 | Selene | 34837 | NULL | 6B8FDB5B3CFBB68DCC553922268EF0587BAB44B0 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.64 | 0.3.2.9 | Cybele | 39475 | NULL | CEB93C2E3D2876FF62BA0DC2F21808346E36270A | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.51 | 0.3.2.9 | Elysium | 26374 | NULL | 34D18949F03875F6B1FCC4F6418CE10137BA7942 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.61 | 0.3.2.9 | Adriane | 39374 | NULL | BD37B322CE0EF1ACA6B7FDD0D66F54504C053BF5 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.58 | 0.3.2.9 | Theia | 37845 | NULL | 594252BFEE13625AC120F50F3015CB3C1DA55690 | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.62 | 0.3.2.9 | Ino | 27364 | NULL | 02B2B98F879CFC70313BB20C4A88AE150E121DFD | | 2018-01-18 00:00:00 | 77.87.79.63 | 0.3.2.9 | Cotys | 34273 | NULL | 10E609E88024C1DB1E8D701602F254C0E8A7576E | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.65 | 0.3.2.9 | Acheron | 35334 | NULL | 94FA1F71A8192C4337F734EC911FBA846045AB54 | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.68 | 0.3.2.9 | Ourea | 27364 | NULL | A75AAE0B7C4A394F3E67DE31E2185EF37F439A5B | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.70 | 0.3.2.9 | Cronus | 34567 | NULL | CAD689550FF6D332698E3687CD0DC40B2475CB38 | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.67 | 0.3.2.9 | Dione | 35334 | NULL | E7C04B1DDE6DFA350A275E88D8612A5380020667 | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.66 | 0.3.2.9 | Atlas | 36543 | NULL | CA318FEF4A3274CBF89416FD580C8B64D6A7589F | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.48 | 0.3.2.9 | Nike | 28376 | NULL | A201E6FAC690713EB25AAE42A18D4C7E277C3B73 | | 2018-01-18 01:00:00 | 77.87.79.69 | 0.3.2.9 | Themis | 29374 | NULL | DCE904F85AC6E399455E9E41584B582CC71B65E8 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.225 | 0.3.2.9 | Gala | 9001 | NULL | D568DDFC9EB8990DB407ADB727DE07A51D835084 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.229 | 0.3.2.9 | Pluto | 9001 | NULL | 4A8B675A0B3C1D6454DBE7A2BD25BF039F596C8F | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.222 | 0.3.2.9 | Chronos | 9001 | NULL | 5C6CA8731F14EFEFEF809533847FD560FB7A9CDA | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.231 | 0.3.2.9 | Asclepius | 9001 | NULL | BBEE2C18269C474539F30016CE427FA5C8D6EB81 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.237 | 0.3.2.9 | Falacer | 9001 | NULL | 0267D63ECED91B436E697A6A09EEBC10EF1834B4 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.226 | 0.3.2.9 | Hephaestus | 9001 | NULL | 9BEBB4DA55DC8C29289FC8929D32B5AC36FEB3E1 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.224 | 0.3.2.9 | Eros | 9001 | NULL | B95EE27634948F7AB399A1E6E43595A9C07B8A75 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.221 | 0.3.2.9 | Asclepius | 9001 | NULL | A7B317D3E45882524B071FF26D02ED5CA3896A94 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.227 | 0.3.2.9 | Rea | 9001 | NULL | 93EA7712DADE2D903A63241C028CDC61828B6474 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.230 | 0.3.2.9 | Caelus | 9001 | NULL | 63829EB51C9E731A1B842CBB887B30F28141C636 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.232 | 0.3.2.9 | Diana | 9001 | NULL | 49D2098FFC4E19F387E6180EEAD8F59EF3F49E3C | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.235 | 0.3.2.9 | Ops | 9001 | NULL | D6EA61F4D08F60278AAFC867EEF7BFFD62693689 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.234 | 0.3.2.9 | Mercury | 9001 | NULL | 407C9F6C0765C30734798999B3F61F9DA44BAACF | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.238 | 0.3.2.9 | Fiora | 9001 | NULL | D9BF6019077878703EF6534B23D2136598E4D09E | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.223 | 0.3.2.9 | Dionysus | 9001 | NULL | 3AEEC2D6F168CC59F46F62531BDF234F5066C30D | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.228 | 0.3.2.9 | Somnus | 9001 | NULL | AE8F5B743EA1D772FD1017CF3DE070FE0CB0A702 | | 2018-01-26 01:00:00 | 185.234.218.236 | 0.3.2.9 | Vesta | 9001 | NULL | FC9AE0DD0B4A03ACA845A534A29B1442B2CB1654 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.248 | 0.3.2.9 | Pales | 9001 | NULL | 7779110F487C0F1C399321848D7879F16CFB7933 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.250 | 0.3.2.9 | Fides | 9001 | NULL | F92479656F51E2C0C29935F75AFE94921D77E8D5 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.242 | 0.3.2.9 | Diana | 9001 | NULL | 742C08BD99FC849BF641331C8A0E5B198CA058D0 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.244 | 0.3.2.9 | Sol | 9001 | NULL | 80F620ABA515A928CBE2D043B4253536F022EF16 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.249 | 0.3.2.9 | Vediovis | 9001 | NULL | FDDF7F36DDD254FDEAE5127F595C5DA0A571034A | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.246 | 0.3.2.9 | Larunda | 9001 | NULL | 17E0D5E328FD6A06D3BD1A1CCB190682D038A7AA | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.241 | 0.3.2.9 | Lucina | 9001 | NULL | 3EEA0DD81D8C4CE243E991538E47CA32EFF5CCC4 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.239 | 0.3.2.9 | Vulcan | 9001 | NULL | 8726F9C47A3703A1F0D79626CDCB0CF0DEB0FDBC | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.240 | 0.3.2.9 | Lares | 9001 | NULL | 084AC15FD4FC3F1229A994D8E8F8ABE8FDD77E97 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.247 | 0.3.2.9 | Feronia | 9001 | NULL | 83F72AB24DE1EC398FF5828C9DB19A6357E573DC | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.243 | 0.3.2.9 | Fons | 9001 | NULL | 5B06421F56248CED92212987F72D27BB4F0BB3C2 | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.233 | 0.3.2.9 | Mars | 9001 | NULL | 25E7317FC422673C537221860B16DD1B3283B88C | | 2018-01-26 02:00:00 | 185.234.218.245 | 0.3.2.9 | Luna | 9001 | NULL | F4DA978E63B181C60C4FC206E9274D46810489ED | | 2018-01-30 23:00:00 | 185.234.218.33 | 0.3.2.9 | Hades | 25555 | NULL | A7F34E65DD14F72E237760216CCB65A99EB9BE59 | +---------------------+-----------------+-------------+------------+---------+---------+------------------------------------------+
On 1 Feb 2018, at 05:31, nusenu nusenu-lists@riseup.net wrote:
If you are the relay operator, please set a working contactInfo and proper MyFamily configuration and drop an email to bad-relays@lists.torproject.org.
We added this advice to the man page in 0.3.2.9. But many people don't read man pages.
Should we also add a warning during Tor's config processing? (Many people don't read warnings either, but it might help some.)
https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/25110
T
If you are the relay operator, please set a working contactInfo and proper MyFamily configuration and drop an email to bad-relays@lists.torproject.org.
We added this advice to the man page in 0.3.2.9.
#24526 did not make it into 0.3.2.9 but it will be in the next 0.3.2.x release.
Should we also add a warning during Tor's config processing? (Many people don't read warnings either, but it might help some.)
Thank you for suggesting this config warning. If it is a single instance operator it will always be a false-positive warning. Or do you actually intent to implement a logic that compares the ContactInfo of itself with other relays and warns if there is more than one relay with that contactinfo? (less false-positives)
On 1 Feb 2018, at 11:36, nusenu nusenu-lists@riseup.net wrote:
If you are the relay operator, please set a working contactInfo and proper MyFamily configuration and drop an email to bad-relays@lists.torproject.org.
We added this advice to the man page in 0.3.2.9.
#24526 did not make it into 0.3.2.9 but it will be in the next 0.3.2.x release.
Should we also add a warning during Tor's config processing? (Many people don't read warnings either, but it might help some.)
Thank you for suggesting this config warning. If it is a single instance operator it will always be a false-positive warning.
Single instance operators do not set MyFamily.
I suggest the following logic:
If the operator sets MyFamily, and does not set ContactInfo: log a warning asking them to set ContactInfo
It should be 2 lines of C code.
Or do you actually intent to implement a logic that compares the ContactInfo of itself with other relays and warns if there is more than one relay with that contactinfo? (less false-positives)
No, this is unnecessary.
T
-- Tim / teor
PGP C855 6CED 5D90 A0C5 29F6 4D43 450C BA7F 968F 094B ricochet:ekmygaiu4rzgsk6n ------------------------------------------------------------------------
I suggest the following logic:
If the operator sets MyFamily, and does not set ContactInfo: log a warning asking them to set ContactInfo
Tor logs a notice level log for missing ContactInfo, regardless of MyFamily already. Most set ContactInfo but not MyFamily, example: https://nusenu.github.io/OrNetRadar/2018/01/31/a9.html
On Thu, Feb 1, 2018 at 2:17 AM teor teor2345@gmail.com wrote:
Should we also add a warning during Tor's config processing? (Many people don't read warnings either, but it might help some.)
Perhaps add this warning to the sample config file as well? And then reiterate this warning during config processing?
Q
tor-relays@lists.torproject.org
-
nusenu -
Quintin -
teor